Watch the 2-minute tour
Herzberg's 10 Hygiene Factors

Examples of Hygiene Factors From the Office to the Plant Floor

Examples of hygiene factors include an overtime rule nobody can explain, a supervisor who signs off without reading, a paint shop with broken extraction and a pay rise that arrives without a reason. Fix any of them and the complaint goes away. Nobody starts loving the job because of it.

Illustrative. Herzberg treated satisfaction and dissatisfaction as two separate scales, so each needs its own meter.

Attuned motivator data runs inside 300+ companies, including

Hitachi
Autoliv
JR East
Kadokawa
NTTPC
KOA

What Are Hygiene Factors?

Hygiene factors are the conditions around a job that make people unhappy when they go wrong: the rules, the pay, the boss, the building. They come from Herzberg's two-factor theory, which splits what people say about work into hygiene factors and motivators.

Frederick Herzberg, Bernard Mausner and Barbara Snyderman built the list in The Motivation to Work (1959) by asking engineers and accountants in the Pittsburgh area to describe times they felt unusually good or unusually bad about their jobs. The bad stories were dominated by the conditions around the job, and those conditions became the hygiene factors. Herzberg's 1968 Harvard Business Review article, "One More Time: How Do You Motivate Employees?", set them out in the order shown here.

The short answer to what Herzberg meant by hygiene factors is those ten. If you want the model in one table first, read the three-minute explanation of hygiene factors and motivators. This page stays with the examples.

10 Examples of Hygiene Factors at Work

One ticket for each item on Herzberg's list. Every ticket has the complaint as you'd hear it, an office version, a production-line version, the fix, and the reason the fix stops where it does.

  1. Company Policy and Administration

    "Nobody can tell me which form I need, and the last one got sent back."

    OfficeExpense claims bounce three times because the policy changed and nobody updated the template.
    Plant floorOvertime goes out under a rule only the shift lead understands, and it seems to change with the shift lead.

    The fixWrite the rule down, pin it where people can read it, and name one person who answers questions about it.

    Why it stops at neutral: a clear rule ends the argument. Nobody finds meaning in an overtime rota, however fair it is.

  2. Supervision

    "He signs off on things he hasn't looked at, then blames us when they're wrong."

    OfficeA manager approves a budget without reading it and reverses the decision a week later.
    Plant floorThe supervisor can't answer a question about the changeover, so the line waits while someone phones engineering.

    The fixMake sure the supervisor knows the process well enough to make the call, or knows who does and can get them fast.

    Where it stops: competent supervision removes the waiting and the rework. The work being waited on hasn't changed.

  3. Relationship With Supervisor

    "I only hear from her when something's gone wrong."

    OfficeOne-on-ones get cancelled every other week, and the ones that happen are status updates.
    Plant floorA team leader who chats with the day shift and nods at the night shift.

    The fixRegular contact that isn't only about problems. Learn names on every shift, including the one you never see.

    Where it stops: people stop feeling ignored. Whether the work feels worth doing is a question for the other meter.

  4. Working Conditions

    "It's boiling by the ovens again, and the fan's been broken since May."

    OfficeMeeting-room screens that won't connect, and an open-plan floor too loud for a phone call.
    Plant floorWeak extraction in the paint shop, and a washroom that hasn't had hot water for a month.

    The fixRepair the fan, the extraction and the washroom. Ask the people who work there which one goes first.

    Where it stops: repairing the extraction clears the air. Nobody stays late because the ventilation is good.

  5. Salary

    "I found out the new hire on my line starts above me."

    OfficePay bands nobody can see, so every raise looks like a favour.
    Plant floorShift premiums calculated one way at one site and another way at the site down the road.

    The fixExplain how pay is set, close the gaps you can't justify, and say when the next review happens.

    Where it stops: fair, explained pay ends the grievance. Herzberg still listed it with the hygiene factors. How far the label holds is covered in whether pay can motivate under Herzberg's theory.

  6. Relationship With Peers

    "I'm always the one covering when they don't turn up."

    OfficeTwo teams that copy each other's managers on email instead of walking ten metres to talk.
    Plant floorThe handover between shifts is a note on a clipboard, so each shift inherits the last one's mess.

    The fixFive minutes face to face at every shift change, and a direct conversation with whoever keeps not turning up.

    Where it stops: the friction goes and the day gets easier. Your own task hasn't changed.

  7. Personal Life

    "I can't sort out childcare when they tell us on Thursday."

    OfficeA move to another site, and a commute twice as long, announced with two weeks' notice.
    Plant floorMandatory weekend overtime announced on a Thursday afternoon.

    The fixGive longer notice of changes that reach into people's homes, and let people swap shifts among themselves.

    Where it stops: life outside work gets easier to run. The work on the line is the same work.

  8. Relationship With Subordinates

    "My crew goes over my head to the plant manager." (a shift lead)

    OfficeA team lead whose reports take every decision straight to the director.
    Plant floorA new shift lead promoted from the line, now supervising friends who still treat him as one of them.

    The fixMake the lead's authority clear, back their decisions in public, and settle disagreements with them in private.

    Where it stops: the lead stops dreading Monday. Any satisfaction in leading people comes from the other meter.

  9. Status

    "Office staff park by the door. We park by the fence."

    OfficeA job title that undersells the work, or a desk move that reads like a demotion.
    Plant floorSeparate canteens for office and production, and reserved parking that runs by grade.

    The fixDrop the perks that sort people into classes for no operational reason, and fix titles that don't match the job.

    Where it stops: in Herzberg's list, status means the signs of rank. Removing a slight ends the resentment. Real responsibility sits on the motivator side.

  10. Job Security

    "Are they closing this line? Nobody will say."

    OfficeA restructure that management neither confirms nor denies for a whole quarter.
    Plant floorA product moving to another site, with agency contracts renewed a month at a time.

    The fixSay what you know, say what you don't, and give a date for when you'll know more.

    Where it stops: people stop reading job ads at lunch. That is the whole effect.

Hygiene Factors Get Noticed When They Fail

Read enough hotel reviews and you notice that hot water only ever appears in the one-star ones. Nobody writes "five stars, the shower was warm." When the water runs cold, it's the only thing the guest can talk about. When it runs hot, it drops out of the review completely, and the guest goes back to describing the view, the breakfast and the receptionist who remembered their name.

Hygiene factors are the hot water of a job. That's why they dominate complaints and vanish from praise, and why a manager who only listens to complaints can end up running a very comfortable hotel that nobody especially wants to stay in.

Is It a Hygiene Factor or a Motivator?

Management courses test this one a lot. Decide first, then open each card to check.

Three Mistakes Managers Make With Hygiene Factors

All three are easy to make in a busy week.

  1. Mistake 1

    Expecting a Fix to Lift Output

    The new canteen opens, and three months later someone asks why productivity hasn't moved. The canteen was a hygiene fix, so it only ever had the first meter to work on.

  2. Mistake 2

    Skipping Them Because They Don't Motivate

    The opposite error. A broken washroom never inspired anyone, but leave it broken and it becomes the thing people bring up when they hand in their notice.

  3. Mistake 3

    Fixing It Quietly

    If nobody hears that the complaint was dealt with, the ticket stays open in their heads. Say what changed, who changed it and when.

What Moves the Satisfaction Meter

Once the tickets are closed, the second meter is the one left to work on. Our main guide to Herzberg covers it in full; here is where to look.

Changing the Work Itself

Motivators come from the content of the job: something to own, finish and be known for. The parent guide walks through a job enrichment example step by step.

Knowing the Model's Limits

The clean split between the two meters has been challenged since the 1960s. Before you build a plan on it, read where Herzberg's theory has limits.

Asking the Person

Before sorting a complaint onto a meter, make sure you heard it properly. Start with these questions for your next one-on-one.

Where Attuned Fits

Hygiene complaints are loud, so they find you. What would move a particular person's second meter is quieter, and it differs from one person to the next: one machinist wants to train the new starters, another wants to be left alone to get the setup right.

Attuned measures 11 intrinsic motivators for each person in a roughly 10-minute assessment, so a manager knows what each person values instead of guessing. Those 11 are Attuned's own framework, built separately from Herzberg's two groups, so don't read one as a translation of the other. As employee retention software, it also tracks how satisfied those motivators are over time and flags drift before it turns into a resignation.

“New hires have never had a company care about their individuality in this way before.”

Josh MoogDirector of HR, Barnett Plumbing & Water Heaters, a hands-on trades workforce · Read the story

Common Questions About Hygiene Factors

What are hygiene factors?
Hygiene factors are the conditions around a job that cause dissatisfaction when they go wrong: company policy and administration, supervision, the relationship with your supervisor, working conditions, salary, relationships with peers, personal life, relationships with subordinates, status and job security. Herzberg's research found that fixing them reduces dissatisfaction but does little to make people satisfied with the work itself.
According to Herzberg, which is a hygiene factor: achievement, working conditions, the work itself or recognition?
Working conditions. Achievement, the work itself and recognition are all motivators in Herzberg's model. Working conditions sit around the job, so they belong on the hygiene list.
Is salary a hygiene factor or a motivator?
Herzberg put salary on the hygiene list. An unfair or unexplained pay decision is one of the fastest ways to make someone dissatisfied, so treat a pay complaint as a real complaint.
Why did Herzberg call them hygiene factors?
He borrowed the idea from medical hygiene. Clean water and sanitation prevent illness without making anyone healthier than they already are. Herzberg saw these workplace conditions the same way: they keep dissatisfaction away and leave satisfaction to other things.
Can fixing hygiene factors increase motivation?
In Herzberg's model, no. A fix moves people from dissatisfied towards neutral and stops there. Satisfaction comes from motivators such as achievement, recognition, responsibility and the work itself, so you need both: fix the conditions, then change the work.
What is an example of a hygiene factor in manufacturing?
Weekend overtime announced on a Thursday is a good one. It falls under personal life in Herzberg's list. Others include broken extraction in a paint shop (working conditions), an overtime rule only the shift lead understands (company policy) and a line whose future nobody will talk about (job security).
Does Attuned use Herzberg's model?
No. Attuned measures 11 intrinsic motivators of its own, such as Autonomy, Progress and Security. They were built separately from Herzberg's two groups, so don't read them as a translation of hygiene factors and motivators.

See What Moves the Second Meter for Each Person

Bring us one team or one shift. We'll show you each person's intrinsic motivators and where satisfaction is slipping, before it turns into a notice letter.

Book A Demo
Running a team or a shift? See Attuned in a 30-minute demo.
Book A Demo